Isaca CRISC Practice Test 59
Question 580
Which response MOST directly addresses this business and information-systems control problem? A bank's approved credit model begins rejecting qualified applicants as its data distribution changes, but risk reports monitor only server availability.
- Investigate the pattern, population impact and systematic process breakdown before drawing a control conclusion.
- Assess report scope, complementary user controls, exceptions and additional evidence for the actual service.
- Add model quality, fairness and business-harm measures to emerging-risk monitoring with accountable review.
- Recommend removing the biometric processing feature rather than funding controls for a nonessential risk beyond appetite.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Verified result: Material drift trends trigger revalidation and documented risk response before prolonged customer harm.
Incorrect Answers
A:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A control tester finds three access review failures in a sample of twenty, but management calls them isolated without investigating shared causes.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Add model quality, fairness and business-harm measures to emerging-risk monitoring with accountable review.
B:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A supplier presents a SOC report with exclusions that omit the specific managed service your organization consumes.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Add model quality, fairness and business-harm measures to emerging-risk monitoring with accountable review.
D:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A game studio considers storing minors' biometric data solely to personalize advertising although the feature is optional and exposure is unacceptable.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Add model quality, fairness and business-harm measures to emerging-risk monitoring with accountable review.
Question 581
Before the risk owner makes a decision, which review MOST directly tests the stated issue? A utility's risk assessment treats a once-in-a-century regional disaster as having the same one-year probability as recurring daily equipment failures.
- Review data flow, threat pathways, control state and process impact estimates.
- Inspect incident categories, service tickets, supplier notifications and recovery results.
- Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions.
- Examine incident logs, control test evidence, exposure and action decisions.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions. Likelihood statements are ambiguous without a defined time horizon and relevant evidence. Next step: Specify a consistent time horizon and appropriate frequency evidence for each scenario's likelihood.
Incorrect Answers
A:Review data flow, threat pathways, control state and process impact estimates. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A risk analyst writes only cyberattack against database in the enterprise register and assigns it a precise dollar loss.). Here examine: Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions.
B:Inspect incident categories, service tickets, supplier notifications and recovery results. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A corporate incident register lists only reported cyberattacks even though frequent failed backups and supplier outages harm service objectives.). Here examine: Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions.
D:Examine incident logs, control test evidence, exposure and action decisions. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A university deploys endpoint protection but continues using the previous residual risk score despite multiple bypass incidents.). Here examine: Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions.
Question 582
A CRISC reviewer assesses: A business unit requests acceptance of a severe customer-data risk and claims security must sign the acceptance because it identified the weakness. What underlying governance or control concept is MOST relevant?
- Risk reports should be tailored to stakeholders' decision responsibilities and information needs.
- Supplier treatment includes workable exit capability to reduce lock-in and continuity exposure.
- Clear control ownership is needed to translate risk decisions into repeatable activities.
- Those who identify and assess risk do not necessarily hold delegated authority to accept it.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:Those who identify and assess risk do not necessarily hold delegated authority to accept it. Apply: Identify the authorized business risk decision maker and require independent risk advice before formal acceptance.
Incorrect Answers
A:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A board receives raw SIEM alert counts with no business impact translation or decisions requested.). The decisive principle for this case is: Those who identify and assess risk do not necessarily hold delegated authority to accept it.
B:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A university's core learning platform contract ends in six months, but no one has verified its ability to export grades in a usable format.). The decisive principle for this case is: Those who identify and assess risk do not necessarily hold delegated authority to accept it.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A risk manager approves access reviews but no identity operations team is named to produce quarterly access evidence.). The decisive principle for this case is: Those who identify and assess risk do not necessarily hold delegated authority to accept it.
Question 583
Which risk-management principle BEST explains the appropriate response? A hospital encrypts lab results but fails to validate test values after transmission, creating risk that altered results guide medical decisions.
- Protecting confidentiality does not automatically prove the correctness or authenticity of clinical data.
- Virtualization changes responsibility and failure relationships but does not remove business risk.
- Recovery controls need separation from the failure mechanism they are meant to withstand.
- Incident handling balances rapid containment, evidence integrity and business continuity.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Protecting confidentiality does not automatically prove the correctness or authenticity of clinical data. Apply: Assess data integrity as a separate goal alongside confidentiality and availability controls.
Incorrect Answers
B:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A product owner assumes moving an application to a virtual server removes the need to evaluate the underlying host's failures and business consequences.). The decisive principle for this case is: Protecting confidentiality does not automatically prove the correctness or authenticity of clinical data.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A law firm's backup repository shares administrative credentials with production, allowing ransomware to delete backups and source files together.). The decisive principle for this case is: Protecting confidentiality does not automatically prove the correctness or authenticity of clinical data.
D:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (An analyst receives a suspected exfiltration alert but operations wants to erase endpoint logs to restore workstation speed.). The decisive principle for this case is: Protecting confidentiality does not automatically prove the correctness or authenticity of clinical data.
Question 584
Before the risk owner makes a decision, which review MOST directly tests the stated issue? A logistics service suffers a two-hour outage during peak dispatch and a six-hour outage overnight with different customer effects.
- Review participant roles, scenario notes, asset dependencies and unresolved assumptions.
- Inspect asset connectivity, exploit prerequisites, data sensitivity and remediation constraints.
- Review service transaction volume, peak windows, contractual penalties and process interviews.
- Inspect required register fields, stakeholder needs and examples of incomplete records.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Review service transaction volume, peak windows, contractual penalties and process interviews. Business impact can be nonlinear and depends on when a process is interrupted as well as how long. Next step: Model impacts by disruption timing, duration and critical processing windows rather than hours alone.
Incorrect Answers
A:Review participant roles, scenario notes, asset dependencies and unresolved assumptions. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A medical research facility's risk scenario workshop invites only infrastructure staff although ethics, clinical and privacy impacts are central.). Here examine: Review service transaction volume, peak windows, contractual penalties and process interviews.
B:Inspect asset connectivity, exploit prerequisites, data sensitivity and remediation constraints. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A scanner finds a severe vulnerability on an offline test appliance and a medium-rated issue on a public payment gateway.). Here examine: Review service transaction volume, peak windows, contractual penalties and process interviews.
D:Inspect required register fields, stakeholder needs and examples of incomplete records. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A risk register lists vulnerabilities and control owners but lacks risk events, impacts, existing responses or decision status.). Here examine: Review service transaction volume, peak windows, contractual penalties and process interviews.
Question 585
Which observation would provide the STRONGEST validation of treatment for this risk scenario? A logistics firm excludes temporary analytics databases from asset inventory because they are created outside its procurement workflow.
- Discovered ephemeral data stores are classified and assigned accountable owners before expiry or renewal.
- The board sees the relationship between plausible loss, resilience reserves and available alternatives.
- The risk profile reflects both measured treatment benefit and the increased exposure from business growth.
- The continuity plan identifies dependencies, service priorities and recovery procedures for actual passenger operations.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Discovered ephemeral data stores are classified and assigned accountable owners before expiry or renewal. Appropriate intervention: Use cloud and network discovery together with responsible owner confirmation to maintain the risk-relevant inventory.
Incorrect Answers
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A small nonprofit proposes a service whose modeled worst credible loss would consume its entire annual operating reserve.). For the stated issue, verify: Discovered ephemeral data stores are classified and assigned accountable owners before expiry or renewal.
C:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (An insurer's risk score remains fixed after a new mitigating control is verified and transaction volume doubles.). For the stated issue, verify: Discovered ephemeral data stores are classified and assigned accountable owners before expiry or renewal.
D:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (An airline's continuity plan covers its data center yet omits the reservation-to-boarding workflow that depends on several external systems.). For the stated issue, verify: Discovered ephemeral data stores are classified and assigned accountable owners before expiry or renewal.
Question 586
After the approved response, which evidence BEST demonstrates the intended outcome? A shipping company adopts a new industrial IoT platform and sees warnings of a newly discovered vendor protocol weakness.
- A reconciled dataset supports meaningful trend comparisons with documented transformations.
- The approved response has an explicit cost and consequence rationale, or a bounded authorized acceptance.
- The risk owner can track deadlines and verify whether completed tasks reduce the intended ransomware exposure.
- The risk profile and response decisions reflect the threat's applicability and system criticality.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The risk profile and response decisions reflect the threat's applicability and system criticality. Appropriate intervention: Monitor credible vendor advisories and assess applicable systems for business exposure and treatment need.
Incorrect Answers
A:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A group's cyber loss dashboard joins incident records from five subsidiaries that use different currencies and incident taxonomies.). For the stated issue, verify: The risk profile and response decisions reflect the threat's applicability and system criticality.
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A nonprofit is offered an expensive specialized hardware control whose implementation costs exceed the plausible maximum loss from its low-value lab system.). For the stated issue, verify: The risk profile and response decisions reflect the threat's applicability and system criticality.
C:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A retailer's ransomware mitigation plan lists twenty technical tasks but no accountable sponsor, target date or success measure.). For the stated issue, verify: The risk profile and response decisions reflect the threat's applicability and system criticality.
Question 587
Select TWO statements: the suitable response and the verification of its outcome. A retailer collects location data for delivery routing and later repurposes detailed history for advertising without reviewing its original stated purpose.
- Unsafe shortcut: Assume possession of delivery coordinates creates perpetual unrestricted marketing permission.
- Action: Assess compatible purpose or establish a lawful new processing basis before expanding the data use.
- Verification: Location processing matches documented purposes and the advertising use is constrained or properly authorized.
- Action: Design separate scoped service identities and appropriate lifecycle controls tied to application boundaries.
- Verification: Representative risky changes fail release criteria and rollback restores the previous trusted identity path.
Explanation
Correct Answers
B:Action: Assess compatible purpose or establish a lawful new processing basis before expanding the data use. Purpose limitation constrains personal data processing beyond technically possible access.
C:Verification: Location processing matches documented purposes and the advertising use is constrained or properly authorized. Purpose limitation constrains personal data processing beyond technically possible access.
Incorrect Answers
A:Unsafe shortcut: Assume possession of delivery coordinates creates perpetual unrestricted marketing permission. Purpose limitation constrains personal data processing beyond technically possible access. Safer action: Assess compatible purpose or establish a lawful new processing basis before expanding the data use.
D:This applies to a different case (A retailer connects three applications using one nonrotated shared service identity because central authentication is considered too complex.).
E:Here confirm: Location processing matches documented purposes and the advertising use is constrained or properly authorized.
Question 588
Consider the following enterprise risk scenario: A board receives raw SIEM alert counts with no business impact translation or decisions requested. What should the responsible risk team recommend FIRST?
- Translate validated risk trends into material service exposure, decisions, treatment progress and residual risk.
- Map binding requirements to common control objectives while retaining jurisdiction-specific exceptions and evidence needs.
- Obtain verifiable independent job logs and conduct controlled restore validation before assurance.
- Combine approved exceptions, versioned configuration control and drift detection with automated corrective workflow.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Verified result: The board report clearly identifies appetite breaches, credible business consequences and required action.
Incorrect Answers
B:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A regional bank runs duplicate evidence collection for overlapping privacy, financial and cyber requirements without identifying where controls are shared.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Translate validated risk trends into material service exposure, decisions, treatment progress and residual risk.
C:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A cloud administrator sends a screenshot stating backups succeeded, but the same account can alter the success indicator and delete restore points.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Translate validated risk trends into material service exposure, decisions, treatment progress and residual risk.
D:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A manufacturer deploys secure baseline configurations but local engineers routinely override them during urgent support work.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Translate validated risk trends into material service exposure, decisions, treatment progress and residual risk.
Question 589
Which observation would provide the STRONGEST validation of treatment for this risk scenario? A telecommunications group evaluates an outsourced billing service only within its own network, excluding the provider processing customer data.
- The committee can distinguish catastrophic low-frequency exposure from modest recurrent losses.
- The scenario enables stakeholders to review the cause and resulting business loss assumptions.
- Each significant risk can be understood, assigned, monitored and escalated using its register entry.
- The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures. Appropriate intervention: Set an end-to-end service assessment boundary covering suppliers, dependencies and data-processing responsibilities.
Incorrect Answers
A:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (Two risk scenarios with very different impacts receive the same orange cell because the matrix is broad and the committee treats them as identical.). For the stated issue, verify: The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures.
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A risk analyst writes only cyberattack against database in the enterprise register and assigns it a precise dollar loss.). For the stated issue, verify: The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures.
C:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A risk register lists vulnerabilities and control owners but lacks risk events, impacts, existing responses or decision status.). For the stated issue, verify: The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures.
Question 590
Which proposed action should be REJECTED as the least defensible risk-management approach? A mobile app delegates transaction approval to a backend API but checks authorization only in the user interface.
- Perform independent review where a conflict of duties could exist.
- Separate an incident response activity from its later root-cause review.
- Assume a hidden mobile button is equivalent to a server-side access control.
- Assess residual exposure after verifying a mitigation in operation.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Assume a hidden mobile button is equivalent to a server-side access control. Client interfaces cannot enforce the sole authorization decision for protected server operations. Safer intervention: Evaluate server-side authorization and transaction integrity across client-to-API trust boundaries.
Incorrect Answers
A:Perform independent review where a conflict of duties could exist. Independent challenge helps detect self-approval. For this case: Evaluate server-side authorization and transaction integrity across client-to-API trust boundaries.
B:Separate an incident response activity from its later root-cause review. Immediate restoration and long-term prevention serve different goals. For this case: Evaluate server-side authorization and transaction integrity across client-to-API trust boundaries.
D:Assess residual exposure after verifying a mitigation in operation. Purchased products do not automatically remove risk. For this case: Evaluate server-side authorization and transaction integrity across client-to-API trust boundaries.