Isaca CRISC Practice Test 46
Question 450
What evidence should a CRISC practitioner examine FIRST to evaluate this risk scenario? An analyst receives a suspected exfiltration alert but operations wants to erase endpoint logs to restore workstation speed.
- Review identity roles, session conditions, network paths and denied access tests.
- Review release failures, technical debt backlog, change rights and proposed migration plan.
- Inspect field device version output, configuration database and change approvals.
- Inspect alert details, data classifications, evidence collection and escalation policy.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:Inspect alert details, data classifications, evidence collection and escalation policy. Incident handling balances rapid containment, evidence integrity and business continuity. Next step: Preserve proportionate evidence and escalate severity based on verified business impact and containment needs.
Incorrect Answers
A:Review identity roles, session conditions, network paths and denied access tests. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A company permits any user connected to its office LAN to access payroll databases without additional authorization.). Here examine: Inspect alert details, data classifications, evidence collection and escalation policy.
B:Review release failures, technical debt backlog, change rights and proposed migration plan. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A startup repeatedly postpones database schema cleanup and now every release requires privileged manual edits to live tables.). Here examine: Inspect alert details, data classifications, evidence collection and escalation policy.
C:Inspect field device version output, configuration database and change approvals. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A utility team cannot determine which firmware revision is installed on several field gateways after emergency vendor replacements.). Here examine: Inspect alert details, data classifications, evidence collection and escalation policy.
Question 451
Which principle MOST directly supports the required decision in this case? A digital bank's risk office directly operates transaction-fraud rules while the payment business believes it has transferred all accountability.
- Independence of challenge is undermined when a function reviews its own control decision.
- Under the three-lines model, operational management owns and manages risks; risk functions provide oversight and challenge.
- Risk considerations should influence strategic choices before commitments become irreversible.
- Resilience planning must examine shared dependencies and correlated failure domains.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:Under the three-lines model, operational management owns and manages risks; risk functions provide oversight and challenge. Apply: Return day-to-day risk ownership and control execution to accountable business management with independent risk oversight.
Incorrect Answers
A:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A retailer's risk function signs off a procurement exception while simultaneously reviewing its own approval as independent assurance.). The decisive principle for this case is: Under the three-lines model, operational management owns and manages risks; risk functions provide oversight and challenge.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A retailer acquires a payment startup, but its board business case excludes the inherited technology and compliance exposures.). The decisive principle for this case is: Under the three-lines model, operational management owns and manages risks; risk functions provide oversight and challenge.
D:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A marketplace places its primary service, backup and emergency communications in the same cloud region.). The decisive principle for this case is: Under the three-lines model, operational management owns and manages risks; risk functions provide oversight and challenge.
Question 452
Before the risk owner makes a decision, which review MOST directly tests the stated issue? A retailer connects three applications using one nonrotated shared service identity because central authentication is considered too complex.
- Inspect service identity inventory, token scopes, secrets and access logs.
- Inspect API routing, authorization logic, object ownership and negative tests.
- Review data flows, threat scenarios, design decisions and pre-release tests.
- Inspect vendor support dates, business impact and migration dependency timeline.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Inspect service identity inventory, token scopes, secrets and access logs. Identity architecture should support least privilege, accountability and credential lifecycle management. Next step: Design separate scoped service identities and appropriate lifecycle controls tied to application boundaries.
Incorrect Answers
B:Inspect API routing, authorization logic, object ownership and negative tests. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A mobile app delegates transaction approval to a backend API but checks authorization only in the user interface.). Here examine: Inspect service identity inventory, token scopes, secrets and access logs.
C:Review data flows, threat scenarios, design decisions and pre-release tests. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A bank adds a new money-transfer API but performs a penetration test only after all architecture decisions are fixed.). Here examine: Inspect service identity inventory, token scopes, secrets and access logs.
D:Inspect vendor support dates, business impact and migration dependency timeline. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A manufacturer plans to replace unsupported plant controllers in five years although a major operating system support deadline occurs next year.). Here examine: Inspect service identity inventory, token scopes, secrets and access logs.
Question 453
Which TWO statements together identify the correct treatment and evidence in this risk case? A hospital grants a departing contractor ongoing access to a research archive and assumes insider threats require malicious intent only.
- Action: Add credible environmental and physical threats to availability scenarios and business impacts.
- Verification: The threat assessment includes credible misuse and accidental disclosure paths with tailored controls.
- Verification: The result presents defensible ranges or categories with the assumptions and limitations stated.
- Unsafe shortcut: Exclude the contractor from threat scenarios because the badge once represented an authorized identity.
- Action: Assess both intentional misuse and inadvertent data exposure arising from obsolete entitlements.
Explanation
Correct Answers
B:Verification: The threat assessment includes credible misuse and accidental disclosure paths with tailored controls. Threat sources can originate inside the trust boundary and may involve error as well as intent.
E:Action: Assess both intentional misuse and inadvertent data exposure arising from obsolete entitlements. Threat sources can originate inside the trust boundary and may involve error as well as intent.
Incorrect Answers
A:Action: Add credible environmental and physical threats to availability scenarios and business impacts. This applies to a different case (A coastal data center models malware but omits flood damage to its single basement network distribution room.). Use: Assess both intentional misuse and inadvertent data exposure arising from obsolete entitlements.
C:Verification: The result presents defensible ranges or categories with the assumptions and limitations stated. This evidence belongs to another problem (An analyst derives a single exact expected loss by multiplying subjective ordinal red-yellow-green likelihood and impact labels.). Here confirm: The threat assessment includes credible misuse and accidental disclosure paths with tailored controls.
D:Unsafe shortcut: Exclude the contractor from threat scenarios because the badge once represented an authorized identity. Threat sources can originate inside the trust boundary and may involve error as well as intent. Safer action: Assess both intentional misuse and inadvertent data exposure arising from obsolete entitlements.
Question 454
Which principle MOST directly supports the required decision in this case? A production engineer deploys a payment configuration directly with no peer review and changes fee calculations unexpectedly.
- Change management reduces unintended impacts through authorization, testing and recoverability.
- Data lifecycle governance covers creation, use, archival, retention and secure disposition across copies.
- Resilience depends on state, data and service dependencies, not only duplicated application instances.
- Project governance needs risk-based controls at stage decisions, not only cost and schedule measures.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Change management reduces unintended impacts through authorization, testing and recoverability. Apply: Introduce independent change authorization, tested deployment and rollback evidence appropriate to financial risk.
Incorrect Answers
B:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A shipping service retains expired customer passport scans in backups and analytics stores after the approved retention period.). The decisive principle for this case is: Change management reduces unintended impacts through authorization, testing and recoverability.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (An e-commerce provider advertises regional resilience but stores session state in a single database region and has never run a failover.). The decisive principle for this case is: Change management reduces unintended impacts through authorization, testing and recoverability.
D:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A city digitizes building permits, but its steering committee approves milestones based on delivery speed while major privacy requirements remain unresolved.). The decisive principle for this case is: Change management reduces unintended impacts through authorization, testing and recoverability.
Question 455
Which response MOST directly addresses this business and information-systems control problem? A utility's water-monitoring process can be manually operated for two hours but has no safe fallback beyond that point.
- Assess risk introduced by the treatment and include it in the residual and connected-risk picture.
- Validate affected versions, reachable code paths and threat activity before assigning likelihood and urgency.
- Determine maximum tolerable disruption and connect it to recovery objectives and escalation decisions.
- Apply a calibrated qualitative or semiquantitative method with explicit uncertainty and expert judgment.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Verified result: The continuity plan states the safe operating boundary and validates restoration before manual fallback expires.
Incorrect Answers
A:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A bank reduces on-premises hardware outages by outsourcing data processing but creates a new dependency on one cloud region and provider identity.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Determine maximum tolerable disruption and connect it to recovery objectives and escalation decisions.
B:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A researcher announces an exploit for a library used by a production customer portal, but the portal's deployed version and vulnerable function are unknown.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Determine maximum tolerable disruption and connect it to recovery objectives and escalation decisions.
D:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A municipal agency lacks reliable probability data for an unprecedented cyber-physical failure but must still prioritize response.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Determine maximum tolerable disruption and connect it to recovery objectives and escalation decisions.
Question 456
Which approach MOST clearly undermines the appropriate risk response? A bank cannot stop online payments but recurring credential stuffing creates fraud exposure above its operational threshold.
- Check control monitoring after production release changes.
- Confirm training effectiveness using observed relevant behavior.
- Define realistic alert thresholds using historical operating context.
- Close the digital payment channel permanently even though a proportionate control response is approved.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:Close the digital payment channel permanently even though a proportionate control response is approved. Risk mitigation reduces likelihood or impact while retaining the business activity and remaining residual risk. Safer intervention: Select layered detection, throttling and risk-based authentication that reduce plausible attack success and loss.
Incorrect Answers
A:Check control monitoring after production release changes. Material modifications can alter control operation. For this case: Select layered detection, throttling and risk-based authentication that reduce plausible attack success and loss.
B:Confirm training effectiveness using observed relevant behavior. Attendance alone does not establish risk reduction. For this case: Select layered detection, throttling and risk-based authentication that reduce plausible attack success and loss.
C:Define realistic alert thresholds using historical operating context. Context limits false signals and missed material exposure. For this case: Select layered detection, throttling and risk-based authentication that reduce plausible attack success and loss.
Question 457
Which approach MOST clearly undermines the appropriate risk response? A global bank builds an independent customer identity service for each country despite a strategy to share trusted platform capabilities.
- Explain uncertainty when presenting a risk estimate to stakeholders.
- Approve every duplicate platform solely because each country requested a separate server budget.
- Define realistic alert thresholds using historical operating context.
- Preserve evidence supporting an enterprise risk assessment.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:Approve every duplicate platform solely because each country requested a separate server budget. Enterprise architecture should translate business strategy into coherent technology design and risk decisions. Safer intervention: Evaluate the design against enterprise architecture principles, shared-service resilience and regulatory exceptions.
Incorrect Answers
A:Explain uncertainty when presenting a risk estimate to stakeholders. Risk analysis can require confidence or range disclosure. For this case: Evaluate the design against enterprise architecture principles, shared-service resilience and regulatory exceptions.
C:Define realistic alert thresholds using historical operating context. Context limits false signals and missed material exposure. For this case: Evaluate the design against enterprise architecture principles, shared-service resilience and regulatory exceptions.
D:Preserve evidence supporting an enterprise risk assessment. Documented assumptions make risk decisions auditable. For this case: Evaluate the design against enterprise architecture principles, shared-service resilience and regulatory exceptions.
Question 458
Which observation would provide the STRONGEST validation of treatment for this risk scenario? An auditor samples five privileged accounts from a supplied list without confirming that several service accounts are missing.
- Test evidence covers a reconciled population and omissions are reported as an assessment limitation.
- Total losses and event counts reflect documented aggregation rules and traceable affected services.
- Expected events enter protected logs after deployment and the independent reviewer verifies sustained operation.
- Supplier performance and customer continuity exposure improve under tracked actions and measurable deadlines.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Test evidence covers a reconciled population and omissions are reported as an assessment limitation. Appropriate intervention: Validate the full privileged-account population before selecting an evidence-based sample.
Incorrect Answers
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A board cyber report counts one ransomware outage as five separate business loss events because the ticketing system generated one ticket per affected application.). For the stated issue, verify: Test evidence covers a reconciled population and omissions are reported as an assessment limitation.
C:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A security team marks a failed logging control closed when a developer merges a fix but the production logging service has not been restarted.). For the stated issue, verify: Test evidence covers a reconciled population and omissions are reported as an assessment limitation.
D:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A customer-service outsourcer consistently misses contractual restoration targets but monthly vendor reviews consider only invoice discounts.). For the stated issue, verify: Test evidence covers a reconciled population and omissions are reported as an assessment limitation.
Question 459
What result MOST directly shows this control or governance problem was addressed? A retail data warehouse copies customer information to a marketing service without tagging its ownership or destruction obligations.
- Legal changes are assessed early and material obligations appear in risk and compliance action plans before effective dates.
- Incident and risk records identify an accountable decision owner and a working cross-team escalation path.
- The data transfer is cataloged, owners are clear and deletion obligations are verifiably implemented.
- Regional decisions remain within documented authority and group-level exceptions are formally escalated.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:The data transfer is cataloged, owners are clear and deletion obligations are verifiably implemented. Appropriate intervention: Update information flow and asset records to identify shared custody, lawful purpose and disposition requirements.
Incorrect Answers
A:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A cloud analytics company learns of an upcoming privacy regulation only after its effective date and cannot demonstrate planned changes.). For the stated issue, verify: The data transfer is cataloged, owners are clear and deletion obligations are verifiably implemented.
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A payment disruption persists because security, operations and product teams each believe another function owns response decisions.). For the stated issue, verify: The data transfer is cataloged, owners are clear and deletion obligations are verifiably implemented.
D:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (Regional offices independently accept technology risks despite a group-level policy requiring executive approval above a defined exposure limit.). For the stated issue, verify: The data transfer is cataloged, owners are clear and deletion obligations are verifiably implemented.
Question 460
Which information BEST narrows the assessment of this particular business risk? A security investment appears cost effective only if ransomware frequency is assumed to be ten times the observed industry baseline.
- Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions.
- Compare published risk methodology, sample ratings, impact definitions and assessor calibration.
- Review baseline frequencies, alternative scenarios, benefit estimates and break-even points.
- Review incident timeline, missing updates, change records and business dependency.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Review baseline frequencies, alternative scenarios, benefit estimates and break-even points. Sensitivity analysis reveals where uncertain inputs have the greatest effect on risk decisions. Next step: Test how the decision changes under credible likelihood and impact assumptions and disclose the sensitivity.
Incorrect Answers
A:Inspect time horizon, historical event frequency and scenario assumptions. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A utility's risk assessment treats a once-in-a-century regional disaster as having the same one-year probability as recurring daily equipment failures.). Here examine: Review baseline frequencies, alternative scenarios, benefit estimates and break-even points.
B:Compare published risk methodology, sample ratings, impact definitions and assessor calibration. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A government IT team assigns critical risk ratings without defining what likelihood and consequence bands mean across agencies.). Here examine: Review baseline frequencies, alternative scenarios, benefit estimates and break-even points.
D:Review incident timeline, missing updates, change records and business dependency. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A distribution center loses inventory updates briefly after a failed network change, but the incident produces no immediate revenue loss.). Here examine: Review baseline frequencies, alternative scenarios, benefit estimates and break-even points.