Isaca CRISC Practice Test 39
Question 380
Which principle MOST directly supports the required decision in this case? Repeated failed access reviews occur because application owners cannot retrieve complete entitlement listings from the identity system.
- RPO concerns tolerable data loss expressed as elapsed time, distinct from recovery duration.
- Control deficiency analysis should find the underlying failure mechanism, not just repeat the observed symptom.
- Compensating controls must be assessed for effectiveness and residual exposure, not merely listed.
- Sensitivity analysis reveals where uncertain inputs have the greatest effect on risk decisions.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:Control deficiency analysis should find the underlying failure mechanism, not just repeat the observed symptom. Apply: Identify the persistent process and data-collection defect rather than classifying each late review as an isolated human mistake.
Incorrect Answers
A:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (An insurance system records policy changes continuously but its backup occurs once every 24 hours despite an approved 30-minute RPO.). The decisive principle for this case is: Control deficiency analysis should find the underlying failure mechanism, not just repeat the observed symptom.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A payment service cannot patch an unsupported component immediately but has a restrictive network gateway and monitored access policy.). The decisive principle for this case is: Control deficiency analysis should find the underlying failure mechanism, not just repeat the observed symptom.
D:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A security investment appears cost effective only if ransomware frequency is assumed to be ten times the observed industry baseline.). The decisive principle for this case is: Control deficiency analysis should find the underlying failure mechanism, not just repeat the observed symptom.
Question 381
What result MOST directly shows this control or governance problem was addressed? A software business measures only the number of data breaches after incidents but wants an early warning of rising privileged-access risk.
- The replacement path is validated before old access is retired and dispatch service remains available.
- The issue is tracked until fixed or explicitly approved with compensating measures and expiry.
- The KRI flags deteriorating access exposure before a breach and triggers action under approved criteria.
- The exception has recorded residual risk, authority, review trigger and evidence supporting continued acceptance.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:The KRI flags deteriorating access exposure before a breach and triggers action under approved criteria. Appropriate intervention: Define a leading KRI such as overdue high-risk privileged entitlements with risk-informed thresholds.
Incorrect Answers
A:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A logistics company plans to disable legacy VPN access before deploying the replacement identity-aware remote service that dispatch depends on.). For the stated issue, verify: The KRI flags deteriorating access exposure before a breach and triggers action under approved criteria.
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A card processor violates a mandatory encryption standard without an approved deviation and labels the violation an accepted exception.).
D:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A manufacturing facility faces a small legacy printer vulnerability with limited segmentation and no credible impact beyond its accepted threshold.). For the stated issue, verify: The KRI flags deteriorating access exposure before a breach and triggers action under approved criteria.
Question 382
After the approved response, which evidence BEST demonstrates the intended outcome? A control tester finds three access review failures in a sample of twenty, but management calls them isolated without investigating shared causes.
- Assessment reports explain failure prevalence, root causes and whether broader retesting is required.
- A sample migration successfully imports grades and the contract gives access through the approved transition period.
- Attack traffic is restricted while legitimate business transactions meet accepted service objectives.
- The dashboard retains visibility into appetite-level exceptions even when routine metrics are favorable.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:Assessment reports explain failure prevalence, root causes and whether broader retesting is required. Appropriate intervention: Investigate the pattern, population impact and systematic process breakdown before drawing a control conclusion.
Incorrect Answers
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A university's core learning platform contract ends in six months, but no one has verified its ability to export grades in a usable format.). For the stated issue, verify: Assessment reports explain failure prevalence, root causes and whether broader retesting is required.
C:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A new API security control blocks known malicious requests but lacks change management and produces false positives on high-value customers.). For the stated issue, verify: Assessment reports explain failure prevalence, root causes and whether broader retesting is required.
D:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A risk office averages high-severity control failures with routine patch compliance to create a single green score that hides a major exposure.). For the stated issue, verify: Assessment reports explain failure prevalence, root causes and whether broader retesting is required.
Question 383
For this enterprise risk case, which shortcut creates the CLEAREST avoidable exposure? A manufacturer plans to replace unsupported plant controllers in five years although a major operating system support deadline occurs next year.
- Check whether an exception has active authorization and expiry.
- Validate significant source data before reporting aggregate risk.
- Record affected assets and impacts when analyzing a risk event.
- Leave unsupported critical controllers operational for years without treatment because a roadmap slide exists.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:Leave unsupported critical controllers operational for years without treatment because a roadmap slide exists. Technology roadmaps must consider lifecycle timing and associated risks, not only planned features. Safer intervention: Align roadmap milestones with exposure, vendor end of support and feasible mitigating controls.
Incorrect Answers
A:Check whether an exception has active authorization and expiry. Exception approval is conditional rather than perpetual. For this case: Align roadmap milestones with exposure, vendor end of support and feasible mitigating controls.
B:Validate significant source data before reporting aggregate risk. Reliable input data supports meaningful risk indicators. For this case: Align roadmap milestones with exposure, vendor end of support and feasible mitigating controls.
C:Record affected assets and impacts when analyzing a risk event. For this case: Align roadmap milestones with exposure, vendor end of support and feasible mitigating controls.
Question 384
Consider the following enterprise risk scenario: A health service encrypts patient records but stores the only decryption key in an employee's local laptop profile. What should the responsible risk team recommend FIRST?
- Clarify crisis authority, patient impact thresholds and communications ownership before another exercise.
- Implement managed key custody, rotation and availability appropriate to legal retention and disaster recovery needs.
- Evaluate server-side authorization and transaction integrity across client-to-API trust boundaries.
- Maintain software component provenance and supported dependency update and vulnerability response processes.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:Verified result: Authorized recovery can decrypt required records after employee departure without exposing keys broadly.
Incorrect Answers
A:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A ransomware tabletop reveals that no one knows who can authorize shutting down a compromised patient-record interface.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Implement managed key custody, rotation and availability appropriate to legal retention and disaster recovery needs.
C:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (A mobile app delegates transaction approval to a backend API but checks authorization only in the user interface.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Implement managed key custody, rotation and availability appropriate to legal retention and disaster recovery needs.
D:This response belongs to another enterprise risk situation (An online retailer builds critical checkout functions with untracked open-source dependencies and cannot identify affected versions during a new exploit advisory.), not the stated case. Correct approach here: Implement managed key custody, rotation and availability appropriate to legal retention and disaster recovery needs.
Question 385
Which principle MOST directly supports the required decision in this case? A municipal agency lacks reliable probability data for an unprecedented cyber-physical failure but must still prioritize response.
- Maximum tolerable downtime is a business impact threshold, not a convenient technology-service target.
- The nature and consequence of a realized event determine useful risk classification and response.
- Threat intelligence informs likelihood only when linked to an organization's particular attack surface and controls.
- Qualitative methods can support risk decisions when quantitative evidence is sparse or unreliable.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:Qualitative methods can support risk decisions when quantitative evidence is sparse or unreliable. Apply: Apply a calibrated qualitative or semiquantitative method with explicit uncertainty and expert judgment.
Incorrect Answers
A:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A utility's water-monitoring process can be manually operated for two hours but has no safe fallback beyond that point.). The decisive principle for this case is: Qualitative methods can support risk decisions when quantitative evidence is sparse or unreliable.
B:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A bank classifies fraudulent wire transfers as generic availability incidents and applies response criteria intended for system downtime.). The decisive principle for this case is: Qualitative methods can support risk decisions when quantitative evidence is sparse or unreliable.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A security team copies every global ransomware headline into its risk report without checking whether the reported technique can affect its own systems.). The decisive principle for this case is: Qualitative methods can support risk decisions when quantitative evidence is sparse or unreliable.
Question 386
Which principle MOST directly supports the required decision in this case? An old medical controller cannot support MFA, and the facility offers a visitor log as its only compensation for remote administrator access.
- Control exceptions must be evaluated for systemic significance, not dismissed automatically as anomalies.
- Risk acceptance is appropriate only with a reasoned understanding of remaining exposure and valid authority.
- Issue management should avoid duplicate work without losing traceable exposure and verification.
- Compensating controls need to achieve a comparable security objective for the actual risk scenario.
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:Compensating controls need to achieve a comparable security objective for the actual risk scenario. Apply: Assess whether proposed compensating controls address the same risk pathway and implement effective restricted access alternatives.
Incorrect Answers
A:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A control tester finds three access review failures in a sample of twenty, but management calls them isolated without investigating shared causes.). The decisive principle for this case is: Compensating controls need to achieve a comparable security objective for the actual risk scenario.
B:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A manufacturing facility faces a small legacy printer vulnerability with limited segmentation and no credible impact beyond its accepted threshold.). The decisive principle for this case is: Compensating controls need to achieve a comparable security objective for the actual risk scenario.
C:This principle addresses a different control or governance condition (A company receives dozens of overlapping penetration-test findings and remediation teams create conflicting fixes for the same shared identity flaw.). The decisive principle for this case is: Compensating controls need to achieve a comparable security objective for the actual risk scenario.
Question 387
Which information BEST narrows the assessment of this particular business risk? A payment company chooses a red alert at 100 failed authorizations per day without considering normal peak transactions or historical fraud patterns.
- Inspect historical findings, operating samples, evidence gaps and root-cause review.
- Review task assignments, timeline, control dependencies and exit criteria.
- Inspect historical distributions, false alerts, incident correlation and risk tolerance.
- Review metric definitions, risk scenarios, targets and observed predictive relationship.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Inspect historical distributions, false alerts, incident correlation and risk tolerance. Useful risk thresholds require context and validation, not arbitrary round numbers. Next step: Calibrate the alert threshold to baseline activity, business impact and escalation needs with periodic review.
Incorrect Answers
A:Inspect historical findings, operating samples, evidence gaps and root-cause review. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A financial institution closes the same privileged-account audit issue every quarter by submitting a remediation plan but no operating test.). Here examine: Inspect historical distributions, false alerts, incident correlation and risk tolerance.
B:Review task assignments, timeline, control dependencies and exit criteria. This diagnostic targets another risk case (A retailer's ransomware mitigation plan lists twenty technical tasks but no accountable sponsor, target date or success measure.). Here examine: Inspect historical distributions, false alerts, incident correlation and risk tolerance.
D:Review metric definitions, risk scenarios, targets and observed predictive relationship. This diagnostic targets another risk case (An airline labels percentage of flights on time as its primary cyber-risk indicator without relating it to a technology failure scenario.). Here examine: Inspect historical distributions, false alerts, incident correlation and risk tolerance.
Question 388
Select THREE statements: the response, governing risk principle and evidence of its effectiveness. A transport operator funds several automation projects although the proposed benefit metrics conflict with its operational resilience priorities.
- Action: Define service-specific tolerances grounded in clinical and operational impact while remaining within enterprise appetite.
- Action: Map each transformation initiative to strategic outcomes and compare risk exposure with the value at stake.
- Verification: The approved portfolio ranks projects using both measurable benefits and resilience risk within established decision limits.
- Unsafe shortcut: Fund the fastest software deployment even when it undermines the operator's required safe-service objective.
- Principle: Business-aligned risk prioritization improves choices among competing investments and scarce resources.
- Verification: Approved appetite statements guide concrete investment and escalation choices without claiming exposure is literally zero.
Explanation
Correct Answers
B:Action: Map each transformation initiative to strategic outcomes and compare risk exposure with the value at stake. Business-aligned risk prioritization improves choices among competing investments and scarce resources.
C:Verification: The approved portfolio ranks projects using both measurable benefits and resilience risk within established decision limits. Business-aligned risk prioritization improves choices among competing investments and scarce resources.
E:Principle: Business-aligned risk prioritization improves choices among competing investments and scarce resources. This concept connects the intervention with its expected result.
Incorrect Answers
A:This applies to a different case (A public hospital's business units assign the same acceptable downtime to an appointment website and an intensive care monitoring feed.). Use: Map each transformation initiative to strategic outcomes and compare risk exposure with the value at stake.
D:Unsafe shortcut: Fund the fastest software deployment even when it undermines the operator's required safe-service objective. Business-aligned risk prioritization improves choices among competing investments and scarce resources. Safer action: Map each transformation initiative to strategic outcomes and compare risk exposure with the value at stake.
F:Here confirm: The approved portfolio ranks projects using both measurable benefits and resilience risk within established decision limits.
Question 389
Which TWO statements together identify the correct treatment and evidence in this risk case? A telecommunications group evaluates an outsourced billing service only within its own network, excluding the provider processing customer data.
- Verification: The BIA distinguishes peak dispatch loss from off-peak downtime with justified business evidence.
- Verification: The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures.
- Action: Set an end-to-end service assessment boundary covering suppliers, dependencies and data-processing responsibilities.
- Action: Record a formal bounded acceptance decision with owner, residual exposure and review date without misrepresenting implementation.
- Unsafe shortcut: Declare third-party systems out of scope solely because their servers belong to a vendor.
Explanation
Correct Answers
B:Verification: The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures. Assessment scope should follow the business service and risk boundaries instead of corporate network borders.
C:Action: Set an end-to-end service assessment boundary covering suppliers, dependencies and data-processing responsibilities. Assessment scope should follow the business service and risk boundaries instead of corporate network borders.
Incorrect Answers
A:Verification: The BIA distinguishes peak dispatch loss from off-peak downtime with justified business evidence. This evidence belongs to another problem (A logistics service suffers a two-hour outage during peak dispatch and a six-hour outage overnight with different customer effects.). Here confirm: The risk assessment identifies outsourced processing paths and associated contractual or operational exposures.
D:This applies to a different case (A risk committee authorizes acceptance of a low-impact archive disclosure exposure but the risk register incorrectly records a completed technical remediation.).
E:Unsafe shortcut: Declare third-party systems out of scope solely because their servers belong to a vendor. Assessment scope should follow the business service and risk boundaries instead of corporate network borders. Safer action: Set an end-to-end service assessment boundary covering suppliers, dependencies and data-processing responsibilities.
Question 390
After the approved response, which evidence BEST demonstrates the intended outcome? A product manager accepts a residual data-loss exposure above the board-approved threshold without consulting risk governance.
- The acquisition committee receives a comparable risk-adjusted business case with remediation cost and uncertainty visible.
- The committee receives a complete factual report and the escalation trail remains intact.
- The exposure has a documented authorized decision, response plan and interim safeguards or rejection.
- The portfolio report identifies the common provider and a meaningful combined downside scenario.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:The exposure has a documented authorized decision, response plan and interim safeguards or rejection. Appropriate intervention: Escalate the appetite or tolerance breach to the authorized decision body and present feasible treatments.
Incorrect Answers
A:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A retailer acquires a payment startup, but its board business case excludes the inherited technology and compliance exposures.). For the stated issue, verify: The exposure has a documented authorized decision, response plan and interim safeguards or rejection.
B:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A security officer is instructed to suppress an unresolved privacy incident before a quarterly audit committee meeting.). For the stated issue, verify: The exposure has a documented authorized decision, response plan and interim safeguards or rejection.
D:This evidence belongs to another risk scenario (A group has ten moderate-looking subsidiary supplier risks but several suppliers depend on the same identity provider.). For the stated issue, verify: The exposure has a documented authorized decision, response plan and interim safeguards or rejection.