PECB ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Practice Test 69
Question 680
An audit of a medical device distribution center establishes an applicable requirement and corroborates the condition that management disputes an observed unapproved stock release at the closing meeting without supplying counterevidence How should a substantiated finding be communicated?
- Assign the most serious possible grading to a medical device distribution center regardless of the agreed classification scheme.
- Link the sampled condition to the verified criterion and supporting records, noting the possible effect on transparency and fairness of the audit record.
- Omit the condition at a medical device distribution center to avoid a difficult closing conversation.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:This preserves factual evidence, the exact requirement and a proportionate interpretation of a factual disagreement should be recorded and evaluated without erasing verified evidence without claiming more than the audit established.
Incorrect Answers
A:Grading must rely on the relevant rules and strength of evidence rather than on the auditor's reaction to management disputes an observed unapproved stock release at the closing meeting without supplying counterevidence.
C:Verified departures affecting transparency and fairness of the audit record must not be suppressed for convenience; any dispute can be documented and evaluated.
Question 681
At a food canning operation, the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement. Which audit interpretation best fits the evidence currently known?
- The process is conforming because a food canning operation has been audited before.
- A major nonconformity is automatically established by the single observation at a food canning operation.
- The situation calls for testing whether findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:At a food canning operation, the observation that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement raises the specific control question of whether findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion. Additional corroboration and valid criteria are needed before grading.
Incorrect Answers
A:Prior audits do not resolve the current evidence that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement; test the actual process against applicable requirements.
B:The signal about accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions may be significant, but scope, evidence, criteria and any scheme grading method must be established rather than assumed.
Question 682
While examining a food canning operation, an auditor finds that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement Which evidence collection most directly tests the relevant issue?
- Correlate current controlled instructions, historical revisions, batch evidence, and finding draft with relevant sampled outputs and requirements.
- Read only the generic quality-policy statement for a food canning operation, without examining transaction records.
- Rely only on the process owner's assurance about a food canning operation without checking source data.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:These specific sources at a food canning operation enable the auditor to investigate whether findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion and to test facts against criteria.
Incorrect Answers
B:A policy statement cannot by itself verify the observed condition that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement.
C:An assurance is a lead, not objective corroboration of the particular issue affecting accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
Question 683
The audit team observes the following at a food canning operation: the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement What follow-up action is most defensible for the auditor?
- End this audit trail at a food canning operation because someone promised the issue would be reviewed later.
- Recheck the applicable requirement and correct the finding before issuing the report.
- Order a food canning operation to purchase a replacement system immediately, before checking any criteria.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:This targeted step tests findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion through relevant records. It serves an audit-evidence function without substituting the auditor for the auditee's management.
Incorrect Answers
A:A future promise does not establish current conformity, especially where the issue may affect accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
C:Specifying management's equipment solution without corroborating the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement would compromise the auditor's role and could misdirect correction.
Question 684
An auditor at a food canning operation needs to record this condition in working papers: the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement Which note is the soundest starting point?
- Use only the phrase 'quality issue' for a food canning operation, without records, criteria or dates.
- Write that staff at a food canning operation are careless and every part of the QMS is ineffective.
- Record that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement; identify the actual sample, objective source and applicable requirement before classifying.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:A traceable observation about a food canning operation allows a later reviewer to compare verifiable evidence with requirements and evaluate the potential effect on accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
Incorrect Answers
A:A label without the specific observed condition and evidence trail cannot support a defensible finding about accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
B:Personal blame and system-wide claims are unsupported by the isolated evidence that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement.
Question 685
A risk-oriented auditor is deciding how to prioritize this evidence at a food canning operation: the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement Which consequence is most closely related to the observed weakness?
- It may affect accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
- It means the organizational chart at a food canning operation must necessarily be redrawn.
- It automatically cancels every existing customer contract held by a food canning operation.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:The condition that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement has a direct plausible connection to accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions; risk significance still requires factual confirmation.
Incorrect Answers
B:The observation concerns findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion, not inherently the reporting diagram. A chart redesign is not the documented consequence.
C:A specific concern involving accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions is not evidence of universal contractual invalidity; consequences must be evaluated proportionately.
Question 686
For a food canning operation, the following condition is reported: the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement Which sample design would provide the most useful audit trail?
- Observe only a preselected demonstration chosen by management at a food canning operation, without output identifiers.
- Trace a real affected output through current controlled instructions, historical revisions, batch evidence, and finding draft, then compare the chain with applicable criteria.
- Inspect an unrelated administrative process at a food canning operation because its records are easily accessible.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:A real trace from relevant source records to an output at a food canning operation directly tests the observed condition and provides reconstructable evidence about accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
Incorrect Answers
A:A staged demonstration alone does not adequately test the original condition that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement; selection bias weakens the inference.
C:Convenience is not sufficient when the relevant control question is whether findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion.
Question 687
At a food canning operation, management claims the issue has already been fixed, yet provides no later operational records. The original observation was: the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement How should the auditor evaluate the claim?
- Accept the verbal claim as proof that accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions can no longer be affected.
- Personally redesign the controls at a food canning operation and certify the auditor's own solution.
- Request subsequent evidence from current controlled instructions, historical revisions, batch evidence, and finding draft and test whether the affected outputs now meet criteria.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Post-action source evidence can show whether the earlier concern about findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion has been addressed in operation, rather than simply described.
Incorrect Answers
A:The statement does not establish effectiveness after the condition that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement.
B:At a food canning operation, the auditor assesses the situation that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement against evidence and criteria; redesign and implementation of controls remain management responsibilities.
Question 688
An audit of a food canning operation establishes an applicable requirement and corroborates the condition that the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement How should a substantiated finding be communicated?
- Link the sampled condition to the verified criterion and supporting records, noting the possible effect on accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions.
- Omit the condition at a food canning operation to avoid a difficult closing conversation.
- Assign the most serious possible grading to a food canning operation regardless of the agreed classification scheme.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:This preserves factual evidence, the exact requirement and a proportionate interpretation of findings cannot be sustained without a valid applicable criterion without claiming more than the audit established.
Incorrect Answers
B:Verified departures affecting accuracy of findings and trust in audit decisions must not be suppressed for convenience; any dispute can be documented and evaluated.
C:Grading must rely on the relevant rules and strength of evidence rather than on the auditor's reaction to the draft report cites an obsolete work instruction as the violated requirement.
Question 689
At a flight catering supplier, an auditor writes that workers were negligent although the underlying evidence concerns a missing second-person release check. Which audit interpretation best fits the evidence currently known?
- A major nonconformity is automatically established by the single observation at a flight catering supplier.
- The situation calls for testing whether finding language should describe objective process departures rather than speculate about intent.
- The process is conforming because a flight catering supplier has been audited before.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:At a flight catering supplier, the observation that an auditor writes that workers were negligent although the underlying evidence concerns a missing second-person release check raises the specific control question of whether finding language should describe objective process departures rather than speculate about intent. Additional corroboration and valid criteria are needed before grading.
Incorrect Answers
A:The signal about fair and actionable reporting without personal attribution may be significant, but scope, evidence, criteria and any scheme grading method must be established rather than assumed.
C:Prior audits do not resolve the current evidence that an auditor writes that workers were negligent although the underlying evidence concerns a missing second-person release check; test the actual process against applicable requirements.
Question 690
While examining a flight catering supplier, an auditor finds that an auditor writes that workers were negligent although the underlying evidence concerns a missing second-person release check Which evidence collection most directly tests the relevant issue?
- Read only the generic quality-policy statement for a flight catering supplier, without examining transaction records.
- Rely only on the process owner's assurance about a flight catering supplier without checking source data.
- Correlate release records, job requirements, sample details, and report text with relevant sampled outputs and requirements.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:These specific sources at a flight catering supplier enable the auditor to investigate whether finding language should describe objective process departures rather than speculate about intent and to test facts against criteria.
Incorrect Answers
A:A policy statement cannot by itself verify the observed condition that an auditor writes that workers were negligent although the underlying evidence concerns a missing second-person release check.
B:An assurance is a lead, not objective corroboration of the particular issue affecting fair and actionable reporting without personal attribution.