PECB ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Practice Test 15
Question 140
The audit team observes the following at a clinical equipment manufacturer: a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release What follow-up action is most defensible for the auditor?
- Order a clinical equipment manufacturer to purchase a replacement system immediately, before checking any criteria.
- Follow two actual hold decisions to identify who was authorized and what criteria governed release.
- End this audit trail at a clinical equipment manufacturer because someone promised the issue would be reviewed later.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:This targeted step tests responsibilities and authorities for disposition are ambiguous through relevant records. It serves an audit-evidence function without substituting the auditor for the auditee's management.
Incorrect Answers
A:Specifying management's equipment solution without corroborating a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release would compromise the auditor's role and could misdirect correction.
C:A future promise does not establish current conformity, especially where the issue may affect prevention of unauthorized product disposition.
Question 141
An auditor at a clinical equipment manufacturer needs to record this condition in working papers: a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release Which note is the soundest starting point?
- Write that staff at a clinical equipment manufacturer are careless and every part of the QMS is ineffective.
- Use only the phrase 'quality issue' for a clinical equipment manufacturer, without records, criteria or dates.
- Record that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release; identify the actual sample, objective source and applicable requirement before classifying.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:A traceable observation about a clinical equipment manufacturer allows a later reviewer to compare verifiable evidence with requirements and evaluate the potential effect on prevention of unauthorized product disposition.
Incorrect Answers
A:Personal blame and system-wide claims are unsupported by the isolated evidence that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release.
B:A label without the specific observed condition and evidence trail cannot support a defensible finding about prevention of unauthorized product disposition.
Question 142
A risk-oriented auditor is deciding how to prioritize this evidence at a clinical equipment manufacturer: a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release Which consequence is most closely related to the observed weakness?
- It may affect prevention of unauthorized product disposition.
- It means the organizational chart at a clinical equipment manufacturer must necessarily be redrawn.
- It automatically cancels every existing customer contract held by a clinical equipment manufacturer.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:The condition that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release has a direct plausible connection to prevention of unauthorized product disposition; risk significance still requires factual confirmation.
Incorrect Answers
B:The observation concerns responsibilities and authorities for disposition are ambiguous, not inherently the reporting diagram. A chart redesign is not the documented consequence.
C:A specific concern involving prevention of unauthorized product disposition is not evidence of universal contractual invalidity; consequences must be evaluated proportionately.
Question 143
For a clinical equipment manufacturer, the following condition is reported: a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release Which sample design would provide the most useful audit trail?
- Inspect an unrelated administrative process at a clinical equipment manufacturer because its records are easily accessible.
- Trace a real affected output through role descriptions, disposition approvals, hold-area logs, and interviews, then compare the chain with applicable criteria.
- Observe only a preselected demonstration chosen by management at a clinical equipment manufacturer, without output identifiers.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:A real trace from relevant source records to an output at a clinical equipment manufacturer directly tests the observed condition and provides reconstructable evidence about prevention of unauthorized product disposition.
Incorrect Answers
A:Convenience is not sufficient when the relevant control question is whether responsibilities and authorities for disposition are ambiguous.
C:A staged demonstration alone does not adequately test the original condition that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release; selection bias weakens the inference.
Question 144
At a clinical equipment manufacturer, management claims the issue has already been fixed, yet provides no later operational records. The original observation was: a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release How should the auditor evaluate the claim?
- Personally redesign the controls at a clinical equipment manufacturer and certify the auditor's own solution.
- Accept the verbal claim as proof that prevention of unauthorized product disposition can no longer be affected.
- Request subsequent evidence from role descriptions, disposition approvals, hold-area logs, and interviews and test whether the affected outputs now meet criteria.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:Post-action source evidence can show whether the earlier concern about responsibilities and authorities for disposition are ambiguous has been addressed in operation, rather than simply described.
Incorrect Answers
A:At a clinical equipment manufacturer, the auditor assesses the situation that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release against evidence and criteria; redesign and implementation of controls remain management responsibilities.
B:The statement does not establish effectiveness after the condition that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release.
Question 145
An audit of a clinical equipment manufacturer establishes an applicable requirement and corroborates the condition that a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release How should a substantiated finding be communicated?
- Link the sampled condition to the verified criterion and supporting records, noting the possible effect on prevention of unauthorized product disposition.
- Assign the most serious possible grading to a clinical equipment manufacturer regardless of the agreed classification scheme.
- Omit the condition at a clinical equipment manufacturer to avoid a difficult closing conversation.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:This preserves factual evidence, the exact requirement and a proportionate interpretation of responsibilities and authorities for disposition are ambiguous without claiming more than the audit established.
Incorrect Answers
B:Grading must rely on the relevant rules and strength of evidence rather than on the auditor's reaction to a shift supervisor and a quality engineer each believe the other authorizes nonconforming-device release.
C:Verified departures affecting prevention of unauthorized product disposition must not be suppressed for convenience; any dispute can be documented and evaluated.
Question 146
At an elevator inspection service, risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments. Which audit interpretation best fits the evidence currently known?
- The process is conforming because an elevator inspection service has been audited before.
- The situation calls for testing whether planned QMS actions may not address operational risks to service conformity.
- A major nonconformity is automatically established by the single observation at an elevator inspection service.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:At an elevator inspection service, the observation that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments raises the specific control question of whether planned QMS actions may not address operational risks to service conformity. Additional corroboration and valid criteria are needed before grading.
Incorrect Answers
A:Prior audits do not resolve the current evidence that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments; test the actual process against applicable requirements.
C:The signal about timely customer service and quality objective attainment may be significant, but scope, evidence, criteria and any scheme grading method must be established rather than assumed.
Question 147
While examining an elevator inspection service, an auditor finds that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments Which evidence collection most directly tests the relevant issue?
- Read only the generic quality-policy statement for an elevator inspection service, without examining transaction records.
- Rely only on the process owner's assurance about an elevator inspection service without checking source data.
- Correlate process risk review, missed-visit records, customer deadlines, and mitigation tracking with relevant sampled outputs and requirements.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:These specific sources at an elevator inspection service enable the auditor to investigate whether planned QMS actions may not address operational risks to service conformity and to test facts against criteria.
Incorrect Answers
A:A policy statement cannot by itself verify the observed condition that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments.
B:An assurance is a lead, not objective corroboration of the particular issue affecting timely customer service and quality objective attainment.
Question 148
The audit team observes the following at an elevator inspection service: risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments What follow-up action is most defensible for the auditor?
- Connect service failures with risk actions and test whether measures were implemented.
- End this audit trail at an elevator inspection service because someone promised the issue would be reviewed later.
- Order an elevator inspection service to purchase a replacement system immediately, before checking any criteria.
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:This targeted step tests planned QMS actions may not address operational risks to service conformity through relevant records. It serves an audit-evidence function without substituting the auditor for the auditee's management.
Incorrect Answers
B:A future promise does not establish current conformity, especially where the issue may affect timely customer service and quality objective attainment.
C:Specifying management's equipment solution without corroborating risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments would compromise the auditor's role and could misdirect correction.
Question 149
An auditor at an elevator inspection service needs to record this condition in working papers: risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments Which note is the soundest starting point?
- Use only the phrase 'quality issue' for an elevator inspection service, without records, criteria or dates.
- Record that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments; identify the actual sample, objective source and applicable requirement before classifying.
- Write that staff at an elevator inspection service are careless and every part of the QMS is ineffective.
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:A traceable observation about an elevator inspection service allows a later reviewer to compare verifiable evidence with requirements and evaluate the potential effect on timely customer service and quality objective attainment.
Incorrect Answers
A:A label without the specific observed condition and evidence trail cannot support a defensible finding about timely customer service and quality objective attainment.
C:Personal blame and system-wide claims are unsupported by the isolated evidence that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments.
Question 150
A risk-oriented auditor is deciding how to prioritize this evidence at an elevator inspection service: risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments Which consequence is most closely related to the observed weakness?
- It means the organizational chart at an elevator inspection service must necessarily be redrawn.
- It automatically cancels every existing customer contract held by an elevator inspection service.
- It may affect timely customer service and quality objective attainment.
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:The condition that risk registers mention technician travel accidents but omit recurring missed inspection appointments has a direct plausible connection to timely customer service and quality objective attainment; risk significance still requires factual confirmation.
Incorrect Answers
A:The observation concerns planned QMS actions may not address operational risks to service conformity, not inherently the reporting diagram. A chart redesign is not the documented consequence.
B:A specific concern involving timely customer service and quality objective attainment is not evidence of universal contractual invalidity; consequences must be evaluated proportionately.